- Get Started
- Write Code
Posted by Mike Rustici
Posted 16 July 2012
No, it’s not. And, dude, you’re totally missing the point.
Tin Can is a new paradigm. To make something backward compatible means to live within the constraints of old. The constraints of SCORM have been holding us back for years.
Innovation and progress require change. Embracing Tin Can will require change; change to how we think as well as to how things work. Change is the price of progress.
Some comparisons might be helpful:
In each case, the newer technology is radically different than the old. The newer technology allows you to do what you did before, but in a much better way. The newer technology requires effort and change to adopt, but the result is a massive improvement in utility. Such is the case with Tin Can.
According to Wikipedia, “a product or technology is backward or downward compatible if it can work with input generated by an older product or technology.” A Tin Can Learning Record Store (LRS) is not required to accept SCORM packages, therefore Tin Can is not backward compatible with SCORM.
But the story doesn’t end there. Just because Tin Can itself isn’t strictly backward compatible doesn’t mean that the products you use are going to abandon backward compatibility. It is possible, and actually quite common, for a product to be backward compatible even though the standard is not.
Your LMS isn’t going to stop playing SCORM content just because it can also accept Tin Can statements. You can still light a room with a candle even though you have a light bulb. You can still play a DVD in your home entertainment system even though you can also use Netflix.
The products that you use will most certainly start to adopt the Tin Can API, but it will be a long time before they stop supporting SCORM. There is too much critical mass behind SCORM for it to go away anytime soon.
I suspect we will see innovative new startups building Tin Can-only products (think Roku, Boxee, Hulu), while existing vendors will incorporate Tin Can functionality into existing products (think Sony, Samsung or Panasonic DVD players with Wi-Fi and “smart apps”).
The point is, that even with the rapid uptake of Tin Can we expect, you won’t need to change what you are doing if it is working for you. If something is broken, or there is something new you want to do, Tin Can will probably be a godsend. If you’re happy with the way things are, you can leave things just the same.